now is it WRONG to have AAAA... songs? (Was: Looping AABA tunes (Was: How do YOU loop?))

[r i c k m o n d <rickmond@yahoo.com>]

thanks for all the insight everyone has been sharing.
this ultimately leads to my followup question: as a
musician who is dependent/fascinated by looping, i've
always wondered - is it somehow WRONG to have AAAA...
structured songs? sure it's entirely subjective, but
it's something i've always wondered. a lot of what's
out there does seem to have ultimately ridiculously
simple song structures or even a two-chord
progression, yet i've heard people say that that's not
really songwriting but more like soundscaping. can
tones and textures do it alone? what do you guys think
or what have your audiences been/not been receptive
to? i'm very curious about all this as i tend to
question myself a lot when i'm composing in the
studio, hence much "song"writer's block and limited
recorded output :(

__________________________________________________
Do You Yahoo!?
Tired of spam?  Yahoo! Mail has the best spam protection around 
http://mail.yahoo.com