Re: What do you think is necessary in order to have an excellent composition?

["Fabio Anile" <fabio.anile@tiscali.it>]

Christophe wrote:
> To me, anyway, and speaking just as a listener, it matters not at all. 
> There isn't any intrinsic or inherent value to forcing music being in a 
> set scale or key or imposing any structure at all, really.   The 
> significant thing is the effect that the music produces in the hearer, 
> which does not  of neccesity depend on any structure imposed on the 
>music.


I'm agree with this concept.
Luciano Berio said that "Music is all that what i hear with the intention 
to 
hear music"
That said, i personally find that climax is the best factor.

About this topic, if interested i can suggest "Style and Idea" by 
Schoenberg
http://www.amazon.com/Style-Idea-Selected-Arnold-Schoenberg/dp/0520052943

Greetings

Fabio
http://xoomer.alice.it/eterogeneo/
http://www.myspace.com/eterogeneo