"So , I am of the opinion that when working in a spontaneous/improvised fashion, most musicians cannot consciously think and compose in both time and frequency domain at the same time"
I think this is only true of musicians whose training/culture are steeped in this sort of Cartesianism. But for those who's episteme doesn't require that seperation ,it's a nonissue. I dont beleive anyone could play Classical Indian Tabla and not deal with both rhythmic and melodic composition, in realtime .That's the very nature of the music ,and the instrument.
|