Support |
Hi Matt, very very interesting point here! My feeling has always been that most people in general like to see the interaction within Bands when they go out to a concert,but i think we have been shifting into more individualism in many areas and the transition is something thats been happening quite a while ago.looking at the history of music in the 20s 30s big bands,ensembles orchestras from classical to dixiland jazz as well as musicals etc.was the norm and musicians were heavily dependent on each other(like marriages perhaps;-)then in the 40īs 50īs and 60īs bands start to reduce, you had jazz trios,troubadours,the beat movement,dylan inspiring people to grab a guitar to play and sing alone. One of the great things people can witness now with the tools we have available is the multi-instrumentalism talent of single musicians,and the gradual buld up arrangements that starts with a single note or riff and the wall of sound a single individuals can create.Thats something that can be really exciting, but i think when is not done right or people just start playing drumloop presets,looping a guitar part and singing along it can easily be mistaken for prerecorded "karoke"and such statements of "monotonus etc. follow.From what i hear is also becoming a standard within buskers in the streets with portable amps and compact loopers like the RC2s. I dont know where looping will go in the future,it is ceratinly exciting at the moment and who knows,this times might be remembered as the "Decade of looping;-)" Luis > The first part of the statement assumes that being able to > deal with > other humans is a requirement for making good music. I > enjoy dealing > with humans. When making music however, it's a lot more > freeing to not > worry about how the other band members will feel about > their parts, or > whether they'll get the same sounds that you want to > hear. It's easier > to be productive in the way that you want to be productive, > without > making concessions to accommodate other peoples' > styles. Some of my > favorite band cds are ones where there's one or 2 > members with the > ideas, and the rest of the band is just there to follow > instructions. > In that context, can you see how it might be more effective > for the > idea people just to make clones of themselves? > > Also, if someone's act just involves playing guitar and > singing, would > you accuse them of not being able to deal with people? > >